I posted this over on my Yahoo Fantasy Baseball league the other day so I had to carry this over with corrections to my blog:
Barry Enright (RHP) takes the mound for the AZ Dbacks tonight marking his first major league start. He advanced from Double A after a 4-1 record with a 2.88 ERA. He is actually 4-0 with a 2.47 ERA in his last 10 starts.
Back in 2007, Barry was on the fast track to make the majors as he breezed through Short Season, Low A and then High A Visalia, virtually untested before starting the 2008 season with the Double A Mobile Baybears.
In 2008 and 2009, he was on again/off again, in 2008 posting a 12-8 with a 4.44 ERA in 29 starts. Batters hit .284 against him.
In 2009, he again was on again, off again. He posted a 10-9 record with a 3.98 ERA in 27 starts.
a 22-17 record and an era around 4 in those years.
The mistake the Dbacks often make is they seem to try to feed on a players hot streak. Often they move a player up, give him a start or two, find out he's not strong at the level, the player may sit in the pen and then moved down a level. These are big adjustments.
This year, Barry Enright has shown success at the AA level and why shouldn't he, this is his second year there. He is 4-1 with a 2.88 ERA over 14 starts but does this constitute skipping Triple A and be thrust into the spotlight? Technically as a "fan" of his, I would say, more power to him. Just like when it came to Jordan Norberto, I said "more power to him". As the baseball guy I am, I have my doubts about the organization.
Enright has not faced any competition above the AA level. While I wish him success, I have to wonder if this was the correct move for the Dbacks who have plenty of seasoned right handers in the AAA level and who are devoid of left handers.
While Enright has found his groove this year, I have seen many a player rushed up based on a hot streak only to see the player go cold. Enright should have been promoted to AAA to gain experience at that level, not used as a spot starter and not get innings on the MLB level.
Come on Hinch, Your wasting arms!
Wishing Enright the best and hopefully they will give him enough innings in the bigs to keep his arm active and strong.
-------------------------------------------
So that was my original posts with some edits. Barry Enright actually pitched a great game, He pitched well enough to earn his 1st Major League win with a 5 inning performance giving up 1 run. He gave up 4 walks in those 5 innings but you damned better well chalk that up to his nerves. Pitching in your 1st major league game is a huge deal.
It still does not make up for the fact that my next post touches on. One of my original thoughts above was "Come on Hinch, Your wasting arms!"
To Be Continued.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Well, you cannot blame Hinch for that move. That is the call of the GM ultimately. Hinch may have had input on the situation, but Josh Byrnes made that decision.
ReplyDeleteAs to skipping the AAA level, many top prospects skip AAA. The jump from AA to AAA is said to be the narrowest as far as the average skill of the players at the level. I disagree that skipping AAA has some greatly negative effect on players.
And where you use the word "constitute", you are looking for "justify". Constitute does not really make much sense in that spot.
I appreciate all comments.
ReplyDeleteYes, skipping levels may not impact a players, many players have gone on to play in the MLB straight from AA. I can't disagree with what you state to be the narrowest skill level being between AA and AAA but that also depends on whether your organization is stocked with prospects or players just being moved up to fill a role.
Although I probably contradict myself with Jordan Norberto moving up quickly, I have often seen where a player starts out in Low A with a 4-1 record and he gets moved quickly to High A only to fall flat. This happens at every level and probably throughout many organizations but my argument stays the same, you have to go with the guy who's been consistent and not the guy who is currently the flash in the pants.
They had Cesar Valdez up and sent him back down because he would get more work in AAA but then turn around and bring up Enright? I have to question that despite me knowing Enright was more likely brought up to fill Dontrell Willis' role.
I can't totally blame Hinch as Byrnes is the GM but Hinch was also directory of player development so Hinch has probably has plenty of say in the matter with his background in that area.
Thanks for your comments.